Sunday, June 16, 2019

The comparison of juvenile and young adult sentencing outcomes in Essay

The comparison of juvenile and materialization adult sentencing outcomes in criminal court - Essay Examplea harder time than adults in courts of law, both in terms of influencing superfluous factors and effecting their eventual outcome, defies conventional theory. Kurlychek, however, fails to present an analysis that enables the study to be applied universally.When demographics are taken into consideration, The Juvenile Penalty presents a study that is far from authoritative. The data for the paper was culled from public address systems Commission on Sentencing and focuses on the 33,962 young adults, between ages 18 to 25, and 1,042 juveniles that were processed in protoactiniums adult criminal justice system over a 3 year period from 1997 to 1999. Not only is there the possibility that Pennsylvania might be a unique case in terms of how adults and juveniles offenders are viewed, the article mentions that the majority of juvenile offenders are black and male tho fails to take in to consideration the role that of racial demographics. Both the sex and race of the offenders and persecutors may play a role in the differing treatment between young adults and juveniles. Additionally, Kurlychek decided to begin investigating cases in 1997, when the treatment of juveniles in Pennsylvania law courts changed significantly. Additionally, if the short three period, in which the cases occurred, was lengthened, the papers disceptation would be greatly strengthened. Thus, this paper needs to evaluate a larger study group to make its argument an effective one.Nevertheless, juvenile status, while never explicitly dealt with in the court room, appears to play a significant role in determining the outcomes of some offenders. The Juvenile Penalty fails, however, to make a universal argument because it focuses upon a small and specific number of cases. Thus, the papers underlying assumptions that juveniles receive harsher treatment than young adults may be accurate but require s additional studies to be proven

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.